Page 1 2
|
Go
 |
New
|
Find
|
Notify
|
Tools
|
Reply
|
|
|
Hall of Fame |
Forget Kidd! Nash is who I want running this team. He's 35 but I think he has 3 years left. I wonder what type of contract he would demand. |
||
|
|
Rookie |
i agree with you w & r. even though his skills have diminished, he still can run the offense. even for two years we can definitely benefit from him on our team. he can still get his 15 pts, 10 assists per game. as long as his demands are not crazy, we should look into obtaining him.
|
|||
|
Major Leagues |
I'd take a 35yr old Nash if it dont mean that
NY Jeopardizes their signing one major nba star in 2010/11 Nash + that star would work for several yrs and he can teach the younger PGs Knicks would have coming in. NY isnt going to get talent easy and Nash wont get a long term contract |
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
How about neither player.
I don't buy this whole mentoring argument. The best way for a young player to get better is to go out and actually play. It's a moot point anyway, because we don't even have a young point guard. Who mentored Chris Paul by the way? |
|||
|
|
General Manager |
Nash/Duhon would be much better then Kidd and Duhon
|
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
Another guy who's best days are behind him...can we please stop with the 35+ year old PG...they are not the future!
|
|||
|
|
Hall of Fame |
I could see why you think Kidd is way past his prime but why Nash? He's still putting up great stats. 16 and 10 last year. Nash is a great athlete. I think he has 3 years left. |
|||
|
|
Bystander |
just what the knicks need another player who better days are behind him,i thought donnie walsh was looking to the future not the past,by trying to lure kidd or nash to the knicks,it seems that donnie waslh is making the same mistake as isiah thomas
|
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
I'll tell you why....because just like the Ranger and other NY teams....these "saviors" get here and wheels come off the wagon. I'm an adamantly opposed to getting star players on their way down, because there is no way to predict when the wheels will come off the wagon. If you could guarantee that Nash will play at this current lvl...that's fine but I don't feel comfortable with that. I'm OK with bringing a guy like that to be a role player or mentor at a good price but to build around or starter? NO! Haven't wee been through enough of this? |
|||
|
|
General Manager |
Nash is not over the hill or as close to it as Kidd is. Nash can still play at a high tempo and run the floor. He still puts up good numbers with 16PPG and 10 APG. I'd bring him in and make Duhon the back up PG
|
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
No freaking way is this a good idea.
Nash would be good for a one year or two year time frame on a CONTENDING team. Think Shaq on Cleveland....that kind of thing. It doesn't make any sense to add Steve Nash....he might be able to get this team to the 8th seed in the weak East, but then what? Are they a championship contender with Nash? Not at all...they will barely be a playoff contender. And then what happens in 2 years when the wheels really fall off the wagon? You find yourself without a point guard and in the same exact situation. Instead, the Knicks should try to find a young point guard and develop him, so that in 2 or 3 years when they are ready to conted, that young PG will be ready to contribute to a team that actually has a shot to win something. I don't think any of you who want Nash or Kidd have made a good point as to why you think he'll be a good addition. He isn't a long term solution, and this team doesn't need any more "quick fixes". Quick fixes are what got us into this mess in the first place. If you really want Nash on this team, why not wait till his contract expires in 2010? Why would you give up anything in trade to acquire him...it doesn't make any sense at all to me. |
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
I couldn't agree more....you sir, understand whats up! |
|||
|
|
General Manager |
Nash is an All-Star PG and he can teach Duhon a lot in the time he might be with us. Plus if we land a LeBron or Bosh in 2010 we'd already have a PG who would only help make both of them better. Just think of this line up if we land LeBron and Bosh
PG: Nash SG: Hughes SF: James PF: Bosh C: Milicic/Curry That might not be the line up come 2010 but its dam good at the Point, Small Forward and Power Forward Spots  |
|||
|
|
Major Leagues |
I'm convinced...Knick fans have learned NOTHING in the last decade!
Catch them on the way down so a year or two into the contract the deal becomes an anchor around this teams neck. UGHHHH! |
|||
|
|
All Star |
Hughes absolutely will not be here in 2010. If Curry is still here in 2010, either James or Bosh won't, certainly not both and probably neither. |
|||
|
| Powered by Social Strata | Page 1 2 |
 | Please Wait. Your request is being processed... |
|
